TaylortrysEngineering Posted April 28 Report Share Posted April 28 Hello, I was wondering if I can get some input from Machinist and Engineers. to give a bit of background, I’m a Mechanical Design Engineer who works for a Centrifugal Pump Manufacturer and Distributer. We have had countless debates on incorporating standards on our drawing and for most it’s black and white but a topic that keeps occurring is surface roughness, in particular O ring grooves. I’m an Engineer from the UK and use BS ISO and ASME for pipes. We have a lot of concession from suppliers saying they can’t achieve a certain surface roughness, for example. For a static application on an O ring groove (BS 862) the surface roughness is 1.6um, our supplier can only achieve 3.2um for example and the O ring in question is like 300mm diameter roughly, which were told it’s impossible to achieve and the cost will sky rocket reducing profits massively, also we have had no problems of failure either. Do we change the drawing or keep dealing with concession So our drawing conforms to standard? I’m a fairly Young Engineer with no machining experience but am desperate to know the capabilities what suppliers can achieve (I know all suppliers are different but seems to be a common occurandr across the board) Has anyone experienced problems like this in the past. Be really good to hear your input/advice. Thank you. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.